Understanding the Social Security Trust Fund
How It Works and Its Impact on the National Debt
The Social Security Trust Fund is one of the most important financial tools in the U.S. government, ensuring that Social Security benefits are paid to retirees, survivors, and people with disabilities. However, its structure and the way surplus funds are handled can seem complex, particularly regarding the borrowing process. This page will explain how the Trust Fund operates, how surplus funds are borrowed, and the impact this system has on the national debt.
What Is the Social Security Trust Fund?
The Social Security Trust Fund consists of two separate funds:
-
Old-Age and Survivors Insurance (OASI): Pays benefits to retirees and survivors of deceased workers.
-
Disability Insurance (DI): Provides benefits to workers who become disabled and their families.
Together, these two funds ensure that eligible Americans receive Social Security benefits. This system is not just a tax; it functions as a social insurance program designed to provide financial protection to workers and their families when they are no longer able to work due to age, disability, or death. Millions of Americans rely on this system for financial stability.
​
What Is a Surplus, and How Is It Determined?
​
A surplus occurs when Social Security collects more in payroll taxes (6.2% from workers and employers, up to a wage cap) than it is projected to pay out in benefits in a given year.
This surplus is calculated by comparing:
​
-
Income: From payroll taxes and interest earned on the Trust Fund’s investments.
-
Expenditures: Including Social Security benefit payments and administrative costs.
If income exceeds expenditures, the Trust Fund runs a surplus.
​
-
The term "surplus" in the context of the Social Security Trust Fund must be defined.
-
Many people hear "surplus" and assume it means there’s a massive amount of money saved for future retirees.
-
In reality, the "surplus" only refers to extra money collected in a specific year, beyond what's needed for that year’s payments, but it's not necessarily reserved long-term for future obligations.
-
The government uses this "surplus" by borrowing it to fund other parts of the budget, issuing government bonds to the trust fund in return.
-
So, while there’s a surplus annually, the long-term liabilities—what’s needed to pay future retirees—aren’t fully secured by cash but by these government IOUs.
How Is the Surplus Borrowed and Put into the U.S. Treasury?
Under current law, any surplus generated by the Trust Fund is required to be invested in special-issue U.S. Treasury bonds. These bonds act as IOUs, meaning that the U.S. Treasury borrows the surplus in exchange for these bonds. Here's how the process works:
​
-
Surplus funds are collected from payroll taxes.
-
The surplus is automatically invested in these special-issue Treasury securities.
-
The U.S. Treasury borrows the money, just as it does from the public when issuing regular Treasury bonds.
-
The borrowed funds are then used to finance general federal spending.
Lack of Oversight on Spending
Once the surplus is borrowed by the Treasury, it becomes part of the general revenue and can be used for any federal program, including defense, education, infrastructure, or even paying interest on the national debt. It’s important to note that there is no specific tracking or oversight that dictates exactly where these funds are spent, despite the fact that this money was collected for a very specific purpose: to provide retirement, disability, and survivor benefits.
​
The lack of oversight raises concerns because this system is not merely a tax collection mechanism; it is a social insurance program that ensures millions of Americans have financial protection when they are no longer able to work.
How Is the Trust Fund Debt Repaid?
The U.S. Treasury is obligated to repay the Social Security Trust Fund when the money is needed to pay benefits. As Social Security runs deficits (when benefits exceed payroll taxes), the Trust Fund begins redeeming Treasury bonds to cover the shortfall.
The Treasury must repay these bonds using general tax revenue or by borrowing more from the public through issuing regular Treasury bonds.
Is the Trust Fund Solvent?
The Trust Fund is considered "solvent" because it holds Treasury bonds, which are backed by the full faith and credit of the U.S. government. However, this can be compared to the following analogy:
You have $1,000 in a savings account (representing the Social Security Trust Fund). Instead of using this money, you take out a loan for $1,000 (representing the Treasury borrowing from the Trust Fund). You promise to repay the loan with interest, using your savings account as collateral. Technically, you are solvent because the $1,000 in your account covers the loan. However, in actuality, you are in debt because you owe more than $1,000 due to the attached interest. The $1,000 guarantees the loan will be repaid, but the interest must be paid separately.
In the same way:
​
-
The $1,000 in your account represents the surplus in the Trust Fund, which is held in Treasury bonds.
-
The loan represents the U.S. Treasury borrowing the surplus to fund other federal programs.
-
The interest is the additional cost the government must pay when repaying the Trust Fund.
While the Trust Fund is solvent because it holds Treasury bonds, the U.S. government is in debt because it must repay the borrowed money with interest. The Trust Fund guarantees the principal will be repaid, but the interest adds to the government’s debt burden.
What Happens If the Trust Fund Reserves Are Depleted?
According to the Social Security Board of Trustees, if the Trust Fund reserves are depleted—which is currently projected to happen in the 2030s—Social Security will only be able to pay out 77-80% of scheduled benefits from incoming payroll tax revenue alone, unless Congress takes action to reform the system. This means that, without intervention, retirees and other beneficiaries could face a 20-23% reduction in benefits as early as the next decade.
​
The Social Security Board of Trustees is a group of six members who oversee the financial health of the Social Security Trust Funds. The Board includes:
​
-
The Secretary of the Treasury (serving as the Managing Trustee),
-
The Secretary of Labor,
-
The Secretary of Health and Human Services,
-
The Commissioner of Social Security,
-
Two public trustees appointed by the President and confirmed by the Senate.
These trustees release an annual report detailing the status of the Social Security Trust Funds, including projections for solvency and recommendations for reforms. Their 2024 report highlighted that without changes to the system—either through increased revenues, reduced benefits, or a combination of both—the Trust Fund reserves will run out in the early 2030s, leaving payroll taxes as the only source of funding. With fewer workers contributing and more people drawing benefits, this would create a shortfall, reducing benefits unless Congress acts.
How Can This Automatic Borrowing Be Changed?
The automatic borrowing process exists due to the legal structure of the Social Security system. The law requires surpluses to be invested in Treasury bonds.
However, Congress can change this system by passing new legislation. Options include:
​
-
Amending the Social Security Act to allow surpluses to be invested in other assets.
-
Creating a "lockbox" to prevent the government from using Social Security surpluses for other purposes.
-
Balancing the federal budget to reduce the need for borrowing.
Impact on the National Debt
The Social Security Trust Fund holds about $2.83 trillion in Treasury bonds. This is part of the broader national debt, which currently totals about $35.69 trillion. Because the government borrows from the Trust Fund to finance federal spending, it adds to the national debt. The more the government borrows, the larger the debt grows, and this debt must be repaid with interest.
What Would Happen If Congress Stopped Borrowing From the Trust Fund?
If Congress stopped borrowing from the Trust Fund, it would have significant consequences:
​
-
National Debt: The government would lose a low-cost borrowing source, meaning it would need to borrow more from the public or raise taxes to cover its spending needs.
-
Deficit Financing: Without access to surpluses, the government would need to reduce spending or find alternative revenue sources to cover deficits.
-
Repayment Obligations: The government would still owe the $2.83 trillion already borrowed, so stopping future borrowing wouldn’t erase existing debt but would prevent more intragovernmental debt from accumulating.
In summary, stopping the borrowing would increase pressure on the government to address budget deficits and could lead to difficult decisions about spending cuts or tax increases.
​
Understanding the Social Security Trust Fund is key to grasping how it interacts with the national debt and broader fiscal policy. While it provides essential benefits to millions of Americans, its structure also contributes to federal borrowing, raising concerns about the future solvency of the system and the impact on the national debt.
Colorado, this is literally our future.
We must do better than this!
​
Send me to Washington and let's Level Up!